Not Good But Good Enough: WKU Earns Tourney Bid Despite Toxic Mark
March 12th, 2012 - 20:07
Western Kentucky became the 14th school in the last 20 years and 21st overall to appear in the NCAA Tournament despite entering the playoffs with a losing record.
The only one of the sub-.500 schools to win two NCAA playoff games was Bradley. The Braves won twice in the 1955 tournament (69-65 over Oklahoma City and 81-79 over SMU) after losing 14 consecutive contests during one stretch in the regular season. Despite the pair of playoff victories, they finished with their worst overall record (9-20) in a 53-year span until going 8-20 in the 1990-91 campaign.
In 1950, Bradley won two games apiece in both the NCAA Tournament and NIT to reach the championship game of both events. The Braves lost against CCNY in each final to finish the season with a 32-5 record under coach Forddy Anderson. Bradley's coach in 1955 was Bob Vanatta. He was in his first of two seasons at the school after succeeding Anderson, who departed for Michigan State after guiding the Braves to a national second-place finish in 1954. Bradley is the only school to go from the Final Four one season to 20 defeats the next year.
Texas, winner of just one non-conference game in the 1973-74 campaign, is the only school with a losing overall record to secure an automatic bid by winning a regular-season league title. Here is a list of the 21 schools to pollute the NCAA playoffs by entering the tourney sporting an impoverished record:
| School | W-L | Pct. | Coach | How Team Qualified |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bradley '55 | 7-19 | .269 | Bob Vanatta | Independent |
| Oklahoma City '55 | 9-17 | .346 | Doyle Parrack | Independent |
| George Washington '61 | 9-16 | .360 | Bill Reinhart | Won Southern Conference Tournament |
| Central Florida '96 | 11-18 | .379 | Kirk Speraw | Won TAAC Tournament |
| Fairfield '97 | 11-18 | .379 | Paul Cormier | Won MAAC Tournament |
| Florida International '95 | 11-18 | .379 | Bob Weltlich | Won TAAC Tournament |
| Florida A&M '99 | 12-18 | .400 | Mickey Clayton | Won MEAC Tournament |
| Lehigh '85 | 12-18 | .400 | Tom Schneider | Won East Coast Conference Tournament |
| Oakland '05 | 12-18 | .400 | Greg Kampe | Won Mid-Continent Tournament |
| Coppin State '08 | 16-20 | .444 | Fang Mitchell | Won MEAC Tournament |
| East Carolina '93 | 13-16 | .448 | Eddie Payne | Won Colonial Tournament |
| Prairie View A&M '98 | 13-16 | .448 | Elwood Plummer | Won SWAC Tournament |
| San Jose State '96 | 13-16 | .448 | Stan Morrison | Won Big West Tournament |
| UNC Asheville '03 | 14-17 | .452 | Eddie Biedenbach | Won Big South Tournament |
| Western Kentucky '12 | 15-18 | .455 | Ray Harper | Won Sun Belt Tournament |
| Texas '74 | 12-14 | .461 | Leon Black | SWC regular-season title |
| Montana State '86 | 14-16 | .466 | Stu Starner | Won Big Sky Tournament |
| Florida A&M '04 | 14-16 | .466 | Mike Gillespie | Won MEAC Tournament |
| Siena '02 | 16-18 | .471 | Rob Lanier | Won MAAC Tournament |
| Jackson State '97 | 14-15 | .482 | Andy Stoglin | Won SWAC Tournament |
| Missouri '78 | 14-15 | .482 | Norm Stewart | Won Big Eight Tournament |
NOTE: District 5 committee restricted to District 5 independents (only two in the district) to fill out 1955 bracket; this rule was changed for the 1956 playoffs.
Regular-season league records of 18 conference tournament champions:
George Washington '61 (3-9 in Southern Conference before defeating #2 seed Virginia Tech, #3 The Citadel and #4 William & Mary by a total of 19 points).
Missouri '78 (4-10 in Big Eight before defeating #2 seed Iowa State, #3 Nebraska and #4 Kansas State by a total of seven points).
Lehigh '85 (6-8 in ECC before defeating #3 seed Drexel, #7 Hofstra and #1 Bucknell by a total of eight points).
Montana State '86 (6-8 in Big Sky before defeating #4 seed Nevada, #1 Northern Arizona and #2 Montana by a total of 12 points).
East Carolina '93 (4-10 in Colonial before defeating #2 seed Old Dominion, #6 UNC Wilmington and #1 James Madison by a total of 16 points).
Florida International '95 (4-12 in Trans America Athletic before defeating #1 seed Stetson, #4 Southeastern Louisiana and #3 Mercer by a total of 19 points).
Central Florida '96 (6-10 in Trans America Athletic before defeating #3 seed Southeastern Louisiana, #2 Campbell and #5 Mercer by a total of 21 points).
San Jose State '96 (9-9 in Big West before defeating #3 seed Pacific, #2 UC Irvine and #4 Utah State by a total of 25 points).
Fairfield '97 (2-12 in Metro Atlantic before defeating #1 seed Iona, #4 St. Peter's and #2 Canisius by a total of 27 points).
Jackson State '97 (9-5 in Southwestern Athletic before defeating #7 seed Southern, #3 Alcorn State and #1 Mississippi Valley State by a total of 16 points).
Prairie View '98 (6-10 in Southwestern Athletic before defeating #2 seed Jackson State, #6 Alabama State and #1 Texas Southern by a total of eight points).
Florida A&M '99 (8-11 in Mid-Eastern Athletic before defeating #10 seed Howard, #2 Coppin State, #3 Morgan State and #1 South Carolina State by a total of 42 points).
Siena '02 (9-9 in Metro Atlantic before defeating #10 seed St. Peter's, #2 Marist, #6 Fairfield and #4 Niagara by a total of 53 points).
UNC Asheville '03 (7-7 in Big South before defeating #4 seed Elon, #1 Winthrop and #6 Radford by a total of 19 points).
Florida A&M '04 (10-8 in Mid-Eastern Athletic before defeating #4 seed Hampton, #1 South Carolina State and #2 Coppin State by a total of 20 points).
Oakland '05 (7-9 in Mid-Continent before defeating #2 seed Valparaiso, #6 Chicago State and #1 Oral Roberts by a total of seven points).
Coppin State '08 (7-9 in Mid-Eastern Athletic before defeating Howard, Hampton, Norfolk State and Morgan State by a total of six points).
Western Kentucky '12 (7-9 in Sun Belt before defeating #10 seed Florida International, #2 UALR, #3 Denver and #5 North Texas by a total of 17 points).