| 1954 |
La Salle's Tom Gola (1st), Western Kentucky's Tom Marshall (2nd), Furman's Frank Selvy (1st) and Duquesne's Dick Ricketts (2nd) |
| 1955 |
Furman's Darrell Floyd (2nd), La Salle's Tom Gola (1st), Duquesne's Sihugo Green (1st), Duquesne's Dick Ricketts (1st) and San Francisco's Bill Russell (1st) |
| 1956 |
Furman's Darrell Floyd (2nd), Duquesne's Sihugo Green (1st), Holy Cross' Tom Heinsohn (1st), San Francisco's K.C. Jones (2nd), San Francisco's Bill Russell (1st) and Dayton's Bill Uhl (2nd) |
| 1957 |
Seattle's Elgin Baylor (2nd) and Columbia's Chet Forte (1st) |
| 1958 |
Seattle's Elgin Baylor (1st) and San Francisco's Mike Farmer (2nd) |
| 1959 |
Marshall's Leo Byrd (2nd) |
| 1960 |
St. Bonaventure's Tom Stith (1st) |
| 1961 |
Gonzaga's Frank Burgess (2nd), St. Bonaventure's Tom Stith (1st) and Bradley's Chet Walker (1st) |
| 1962 |
Holy Cross' Jack Foley (2nd) and Bradley's Chet Walker (1st) |
| 1963 |
Colorado State's Bill Green (2nd), Loyola of Chicago's Jerry Harkness (1st), NYU's Barry Kramer (1st) and Bowling Green State's Nate Thurmond (2nd) |
| 1964 |
Princeton's Bill Bradley (1st), Davidson's Fred Hetzel (2nd) and Wichita State's Dave Stallworth (1st) |
| 1965 |
Princeton's Bill Bradley (1st), Utah State's Wayne Estes (2nd), Davidson's Fred Hetzel (1st) and Wichita State's Dave Stallworth (2nd) |
| 1966 |
St. Joseph's Matt Guokas (2nd) and Davidson's Dick Snyder (2nd) |
| 1967 |
New Mexico's Mel Daniels (2nd), Western Kentucky's Clem Haskins (1st) and Dayton's Don May (2nd) |
| 1968 |
St. Bonaventure's Bob Lanier (2nd), Dayton's Don May (2nd) and Niagara's Calvin Murphy (2nd) |
| 1969 |
Detroit's Spencer Haywood (1st), Davidson's Mike Maloy (2nd), Niagara's Calvin Murphy (1st) and Santa Clara's Bud Ogden (2nd) |
| 1970 |
New Mexico State's Jimmy Collins (2nd), St. Bonaventure's Bob Lanier (1st) and Niagara's Calvin Murphy (1st) |
| 1971 |
La Salle's Ken Durrett (2nd), Jacksonville's Artis Gilmore (1st) and Western Kentucky's Jim McDaniels (1st) |
| 1972 |
Oral Roberts' Richie Fuqua (2nd), Southwestern Louisiana's Dwight "Bo" Lamar (1st) and Long Beach State's Ed Ratleff (1st) |
| 1973 |
Illinois State's Doug Collins (1st), Southwestern Louisiana's Dwight "Bo" Lamar (1st), Long Beach State's Ed Ratleff (1st) and American University's Kermit Washington (2nd) |
| 1974 |
Canisius' Larry Fogle (2nd) |
| 1975 |
none |
| 1976 |
none |
| 1977 |
San Francisco's Bill Cartwright (2nd) |
| 1978 |
Indiana State's Larry Bird (1st) and Portland State's Freeman Williams (2nd) |
| 1979 |
Indiana State's Larry Bird (1st), San Francisco's Bill Cartwright (2nd), Northeast Louisiana's Calvin Natt (2nd), Dayton's Jim Paxson (2nd) and Rhode Island's Sly Williams (2nd) |
| 1980 |
La Salle's Michael Brooks (1st) |
| 1981 |
Brigham Young's Danny Ainge (1st) |
| 1982 |
San Francisco's Quintin Dailey (1st), UC Irvine's Kevin Magee (2nd) and Tulsa's Paul Pressey (2nd) |
| 1983 |
UNLV's Sidney Green (2nd) |
| 1984 |
San Diego State's Michael Cage (2nd), Brigham Young's Devin Durrant (2nd) and Cal State Fullerton's Leon Wood (2nd) |
| 1985 |
Wichita State's Xavier McDaniel (1st) |
| 1986 |
Miami of Ohio's Ron Harper (2nd) and Navy's David Robinson (2nd) |
| 1987 |
UNLV's Armon Gilliam (2nd) and Navy's David Robinson (1st) |
| 1988 |
Bradley's Hersey Hawkins (1st) and Brigham Young's Michael Smith (2nd) |
| 1989 |
La Salle's Lionel Simmons (2nd) |
| 1990 |
Loyola Marymount's Hank Gathers (2nd), UNLV's Larry Johnson (1st), Loyola Marymount's Bo Kimble (2nd) and La Salle's Lionel Simmons (1st) |
| 1991 |
UNLV's Stacey Augmon (2nd), East Tennessee State's Keith "Mister" Jennings (2nd) and UNLV's Larry Johnson (1st) |
| 1992 |
none |
| 1993 |
UNLV's J.R. Rider (2nd) |
| 1994 |
none |
| 1995 |
Massachusetts' Lou Roe (2nd) |
| 1996 |
Massachusetts' Marcus Camby (1st) |
| 1997 |
none |
| 1998 |
none |
| 1999 |
Miami of Ohio's Wally Szczerbiak (2nd) |
| 2000 |
Fresno State's Courtney Alexander (2nd) |
| 2001 |
none |
| 2002 |
Gonzaga's Dan Dickau (1st) and Xavier's David West (2nd) |
| 2003 |
Creighton's Kyle Korver (2nd) and Xavier's David West (1st) |
| 2004 |
St. Joseph's Jameer Nelson (1st) and Gonzaga's Blake Stepp (2nd) |
| 2005 |
none |
| 2006 |
Gonzaga's Adam Morrison (1st) |
| 2007 |
Nevada's Nick Fazekas (2nd) |
| 2008 |
Davidson's Stephen Curry (2nd) |
| 2009 |
Davidson's Stephen Curry (1st) |
| 2010 |
none |
| 2011 |
Morehead State's Kenneth Faried (2nd), Brigham Young's Jimmer Fredette (1st) and San Diego State's Kawhi Leonard (2nd) |
| 2012 |
Murray State's Isaiah Canaan (2nd) and Creighton's Doug McDermott (1st) |
| 2013 |
Creighton's Doug McDermott (1st) and Gonzaga's Kelly Olynyk (1st) |
