Slow Start: Five All-Americans Averaged < 4 PPG in Their Freshman Seasons

In a microwave atmosphere of instant expectations, please be aware that five All-Americans this season failed to generate national headlines in their freshman campaigns by averaging fewer than 4 ppg - Houston's LJ Cryer (3.4 ppg with Baylor in 2020-21), Villanova's Eric Dixon (3 ppg in 2020-21), Memphis' PJ Haggerty (2.8 ppg with TCU in six games in 2022-23), Tennessee's Chaz Lanier (1.7 ppg with North Florida in 10 games in 2020-21) and Wisconsin's John Tonje (3.6 ppg with Colorado State in 2019-20).

Iowa's Kris Murray (0.6 ppg in 2020-21), posting the lowest-ever freshman scoring average for an eventual All-American, isn't the only standout enduring growing pains early in college career. The following alphabetical list of players averaged fewer than three points per game as a freshman before eventually earning All-American acclaim:

Eventual All-American Pos. A-A School Freshman Scoring Average
Cole Aldrich C Kansas 2.8 ppg in 2007-08
Lorenzo Charles F North Carolina State 2.2 ppg in 1981-82
Rakeem Christmas F Syracuse 2.8 ppg in 2011-12
Keith Edmonson G Purdue 1.3 ppg in 1978-79
Aaron Gray C Pittsburgh 1.7 ppg in 2003-04
Erick Green G Virginia Tech 2.6 ppg in 2009-10
Tom Gugliotta F North Carolina State 2.7 ppg in 1988-89
Rui Hachimura F Gonzaga 2.6 ppg in 2016-17
PJ Haggerty G Memphis 2.8 ppg in 2022-23 with TCU
Roy Hamilton G UCLA 1.2 ppg in 1975-76
Jeff Jonas G Utah 2.8 ppg in 1973-74
Johnny Juzang G UCLA 2.9 ppg in 2019-20 with Kentucky
Frank Kaminsky C-F Wisconsin 1.8 ppg in 2011-12
Ted Kitchel F Indiana 1.7 ppg in 1979-80
Bob Kurland C Oklahoma A&M 2.5 ppg in 1942-43
Tom LaGarde C North Carolina 2.2 ppg in 1973-74
Jock Landale C Saint Mary's 2.1 ppg in 2014-15
Chaz Lanier G Tennessee 1.7 ppg in 2020-21 with North Florida
Kenyon Martin C Cincinnati 2.8 ppg in 1996-97
Luke Maye F North Carolina 1.2 ppg in 2015-16
Kris Murray F Iowa 0.6 ppg in 2020-21
John Pilch G Wyoming 2.4 ppg in 1946-47
Thomas Robinson F Kansas 2.5 ppg in 2009-10
Steve Scheffler C Purdue 1.5 ppg in 1986-87
Russ Smith G Louisville 2.2 ppg in 2010-11
Earl Tatum G-F Marquette 1.5 ppg in 1972-73
Kurt Thomas F-C Texas Christian 0.8 ppg in 1990-91
Al Thornton F Florida State 2.8 ppg in 2003-04
B.J. Tyler G Texas 2.9 ppg in 1989-90 with DePaul
Scottie Wilbekin G Florida 2.4 ppg in 2010-11
Jeff Withey C Kansas 1.3 ppg in 2009-10

NOTES: Oregon's Wally Borrevik (1.8 ppg in 1940-41), Wisconsin's Gene Englund (2.3 ppg in 1938-39), California's Darrall Imhoff (0.9 ppg in 1957-58), Kansas' Dean Kelley (0.8 in 1950-51), Purdue's Bob Kessler (2.3 ppg in 1933-34), Notre Dame's Leo Klier (2.7 in 1942-43), Oklahoma A&M's Gale McArthur (2.96 ppg in 1948-49), Notre Dame's Bob Rensberger (1.5 ppg in 1940-41) and Stanford's George Yardley (2.9 ppg in 1947-48) averaged fewer than three points per game as sophomores when freshmen weren't eligible to play varsity basketball before becoming All-Americans. . . . Withey originally attended Arizona.