False Starts: Utah State and West Virginia Prone to Early NCAA Playoff Exits
North Carolina A&T appeared in the NCAA playoffs the most times (nine) without winning a tournament game until prevailing in 2013 First Four. But N.C. A&T still has a long way to go to join the ranks of "quick-exit" schools such as battered Brigham Young, the only institution with as many as 20 opening-round reversals in NCAA tourney.
Connecticut, after absorbing nine opening-round losses in 17 years from 1951 through 1967, had the most opening-round setbacks for an extended period. But the Huskies didn't incur an opening-round reversal for 28 years until suffering two in a recent five-year span before leaving again early in back-to-back recent playoffs. Similarly, St. John's suffered eight opening-round losses in a 20-year stretch from 1973 through 1992.
Maryland was the first school to incur at least 10 NCAA Tournament defeats but never absorb an opening-round setback until the Terrapins lost to Santa Clara in 1996. Mizzou's loss against former Big Eight/Big 12 rival Oklahoma, eight years after toothless Tigers were embarrassed by Norfolk State despite being favored by more than 20 points, left them among the following schools most prone to sustaining an opening-round NCAA tourney defeat:
School (Playoff Losses) NCAA Tournament Opening-Round Defeats Brigham Young (33) 20 (1950-57-65-69-72-79-80-87-90-92-95-01-03-04-07-08-09-14-15-21) Utah State (23) 19 (1939-63-71-75-79-80-83-88-98-00-03-05-06-09-10-11-19-21-23) Princeton (29) 17 (1952-55-60-63-69-76-77-81-89-90-91-92-97-01-04-11-17) Temple (33) 16 (1944-64-67-70-72-79-90-92-95-98-08-09-10-12-16-19) Missouri (28) 16 (1944-78-81-83-86-87-88-90-93-99-00-11-12-13-18-21) St. John's (32) 15 (1961-68-73-76-77-78-80-84-88-92-98-02-11-15-19) West Virginia (28) 15 (1955-56-57-58-62-65-67-83-86-87-92-09-12-16-23)