Playing Favorites: UVA is #1 Seed Despite Failing to Earn Conference Crown

The sampling isn't extensive but Virginia, runner-up to North Carolina in both the ACC regular season and tournament, aspires to duplicate what defending NCAA champion Duke achieved last year in capturing the NCAA championship after the Blue Devils were accorded a #1 seed despite failing to win either the ACC regular-season or conference tournament title. Following is a chronological list detailing what happened in the NCAA tourney to the first six #1 seeds in this non-regular-season champion category:

No. 1 Seed Year League Finish NCAA Playoff Result Summary of Principal Conference Competition
Illinois 1989 2nd in Big Ten lost in national semifinals regular-season champion Indiana lost in regional semifinals; Big Ten did not conduct postseason tourney
Michigan 1993 2nd in Big Ten lost in national final regular-season champion Indiana lost in regional final; Big Ten did not conduct postseason tourney
Texas 2003 2nd in Big 12 lost in national semifinals regular-season champion Kansas lost in national final; Big 12 tourney champion Oklahoma lost in regional final
Connecticut 2009 T2nd in Big East lost in national semifinals regular-season and Big East tourney champion Louisville lost in regional final
Pittsburgh 2009 T2nd in Big East lost in regional final regular-season and Big East tourney champion Louisville lost in regional final
Duke 2015 2nd in ACC won NCAA title regular-season champion North Carolina lost in regional semifinals